Typically, a big bad wolf doesn’t come in the form of the oh-so-handsome Johnny Depp, but such is the case for the upcoming flick Into the Woods. The first look at the 51-year-old actor in character as The Wolf appears on this week’s Entertainment Weekly cover, along with a shot of Lilla Crawford as Little Red Riding Hood—and it’s safe to say we’re fully enchanted by the thesp’s transformation. Flashing a menacing look on mug, Depp’s hands are covered in fur, his eyebrows are bushier than ever and he’s sporting one of the creepiest mustaches we’ve ever seen.