We’ve all played “Never Have I Ever” before–perhaps with five fingers or as a drinking game at a party–and as bad as we thought it was airing our dirty laundry to a small group of friends, we’ve never been forced to do it on national television. But Ellen DeGeneres doesn’t care about that! During Thursday’s episode with Gwyneth Paltrow, Johnny Depp and Paul Bettany–who are all promoting their latest movie Mortdecai–the talk show host got the three actors to participate in the game and reveal some of their naughty secrets. Of course DeGeneres kicked the game off on an inappropriate note, saying, “Never have I ever been to a nude beach.” At first Depp was the only one to admit he had, but Bettany finally flipped his paddle back to reveal he had, indeed, been to one as well.