For Aaron Carter, Hilary Duff will always be the one who got away. More than a decade after the “That’s How I Beat Shaq” singer and the Lizzie McGuire star called it quits, Carter repeatedly professed his love for his ex-girlfriend on Twitter and in interviews. Ignoring the fact that Duff is still married to ex-hockey player Mike Comrie, Carter’s gushy tweets quickly turned creepy. Andy Cohen asked Duff how it felt to have Carter “declaring his love” for her on Bravo’s Watch What Happens Live Wednesday. The Younger actress, 27, asked, “Really? I’m going to hurt you right now.” Cohen said, “He’s just feeling you on Twitter publicly.” Duff replied, “It’s nice to be felt.”
