Growing up geeky isn’t always fun in the moment, but boy, does it build character! On Thursday’s Jimmy Kimmel Live!, the late-night host and his guest Ryan Seacrest bonded over their admittedly awkward childhood photos. Both fellas also joked about the fact they were featured in People’s 2014 Sexiest Man Alive “Geeky to Gorgeous” section. The late-night host wanted to know “what it would be like if that duo [young Ryan and young Jimmy] hung out together,” so he Photoshopped a picture of the twosome together as kids.