when E! News hit the gorgeous set of Bachelor in Paradise in Mexico, we asked fan-favorites such as Ashley Iaconetti, Ashley Salter, Tenley Molzahn, Mikey Tenerelli and more to reveal who they were hoping to date in Paradise and their answers are definitely…surprising! It sounds like Clare Crawley, the only cast member to return from the first season, was a popular pick among the BIP men as Mikey told us, “Clare was one of my numbers ones,” and Kirk DeWindt also said, “I was hoping Tenley and Clare would be here!” Unfortunately for Kirk, Tenley said she’d been out of the Bachelor game for so long (last appearing on Bachelor Pad), joking that she “needed a poster of all the men” to choose from.
